Amazon.com Widgets
The Linde

Indicate rss Click here to subscribe to our RSS feed

Showing only entries tagged with: Pluralism  |  Display all entries

Another burqa photo | Katie van Schaijik
Tags: burqa, freedom of religion, pluralism

It didn’t seem quite right to add this to Josef Seifert’s post defending the “freedom” (I can’t help adding the scare quotes) to wear the burqa, but I post it for the sake of making clear the sort of thing I have in mind. No conciliating baby blue this time.

I’ve also just come across an article in today’s Daily Mail [a UK paper] on the subject: a British Muslim woman making the case for banning the burqa in public. I won’t link it directly (because of the racy gossip also featured), but here’s a key passage:

Many of my adult British Muslim friends cover their heads with a headscarf - and I have no problem with that.

The burkha is an entirely different matter. It is an imported Saudi Arabian tradition, and the growing number of women veiling their faces in Britain is a sign of creeping radicalisation, which is not just regressive, it is oppressive and downright dangerous.

The burkha is an extreme practice. It is never right for a woman to hide behind a veil and shut herself off from people in the community. But it is particularly wrong in Britain, where it is alien to the mainstream culture for someone to walk around wearing a mask.

The veil restricts women. It stops them achieving their full potential in all areas of their life, and it stops them communicating. It sends out a clear message: “I do not want to be part of your society.”

Every time the burkha is debated, Muslim fundamentalists bring out all these women who say: “It’s my choice to wear this.”

Perhaps so - but what pressures have been brought to bear on them? The reality, surely, is that a lot of women are not free to choose.

Girls as young as four are wearing the hijab to school: that is not a freely made choice. It stops them taking part in education and reaching their potential, and the idea that tiny children need to protect their modesty is abhorrent.

And behind the closed doors of some Muslim houses, countless-young women are told to wear the hijab and the veil. These are the girls who are hidden away, they are not allowed to go to university or choose who they marry. In many cases, they are kept down by the threat of violence.

The burkha is the ultimate visual symbol of female oppression. It is the weapon of radical Muslim men who want to see Sharia law on Britain’s streets, and would love women to be hidden, unseen and unheard. It is totally out of place in a civilised country.

Precisely because it is impossible to distinguish between the woman who is choosing to wear a burkha and the girl who has been forced to cover herself and live behind a veil, I believe it should be banned.

Jun 23, 7:24 pm

5 comments

Should burquas be banned? | Katie van Schaijik
Tags: burqa, freedom of religion, pluralism

Sarkozy says that burqas are not welcome in France.

I would like to know what personalist philosophers say to this. We favor the free expression of religion, while we oppose the oppression of women in Islam embodied in the burqa. What’s a pluralistic society to do?

Jun 22, 1:23 pm

8 comments

Page 1 of 1 pages

Join our mailing list:

  

It is no ordinary matter we are discussing, Glaucon, but the right conduct of life.

Socrates, The Republic

Email the Linde

Interesting series:

Josef Seifert on the nature and importance of freedom:

Are we free? Are we persons?
Why nothing is left of Jewish Christian Faith if we are not free.
But are we free? Five questions.
What Is Freedom? Can We choose Radically Different Lives?
Inner Freedom and Cooperative Freedom
Are we really free? Can we know it?
The first three evidences for human freedom
Fourth, denying freedom is self-contradictory
Fifth, the evidence from everyone's experience
…  to be continued

John Crosby on the philosophy of John Paul II:

Flying With Both Wings: Why Christians Need Philosophy
Worthy of Respect: The Personalist Norm
Interiority of Human Persons
Persons Are Unrepeatable
Human Freedom
Freedom and Truth
Self-Donation
Embodiment
Embodiment and Morality
10  Solidarity

The Christopher West controversy:

•  The Nightline interview that started it all
•  Alice von Hildebrand's critique
•  David Schindler's critique
•  Fr. Angelo Geiger weighs in
•  A word by West himself
•  Janet Smith's defense
•  Michael Waldstein's defense
•  Schindler responds to Smith and Waldstein
•  Janet Smith's second counter
•  Fr. Angelo Geiger weighs in a 2nd time
•  West's response to the controversy

Find lectures by Healy and West in our downloads section, or listen to specific topics:
- the JPII - Hefner comparison
- prudishness
- concupiscence
- on sexual intimacy as self-revealing

Tags (i.e. topics):

abortionabortion survivalalice von hildebrandalinskyangeranimal rightsapartheidapologiaapprehensionarchbishop chaputatheismauthenticityayn randbeatificationbenedictbenedict xvibenjamin franklinbureaucracyburqacall to lovecare for the soulcaritas in veritatecaryll houselandercentral planningcharitycharles taylorchild brideschild psychologychildrenchristian faithchristmaschristopher caldwellchristopher westcivilitycloningclosed postscoercioncolonialismcommunioncommunismcommunityconcupiscencecondomsconjugal loveconjugal rightsconscienceconscience and super-egoconservatismcourtshipcriticismcrosbycultish tendenciesculturedamien of molokaidavid brooksde lubacdeferencedeterminismdietrich von hildebranddignitydignity of womendistance educationdreyfus affairdysfunctionecumenismedith steineducationeinsteinembryonic stem cell researchemotionemotional drynessemptinessenvironmentalismequalityetiquetteexperience of free willexpertisefaithfatherhoodfaultsfeelingsfeminismfoolsforgivenessfrankensteinfree willfreedomfreedom of religionfriendshipfulton sheengeorge weigelgianna jessengift of selfgoofygratitudehans jonashappinesshardwiringhavelhealth carehealyhefnerhenri bergsonhugh hefnerhuman rightsideologyillative senseimmigrationincarnationindividualismindividualityinnocenceinstitutional failureintimacyintimidationiranislamjansenismjason berryjohn cagejohn paul iijosef seifertjournalismjust warjusticekierkegaardkleistkoranlawlerlegion of christleon podlesliberalismlonelinesslovemacintyremanipulationmao tse tungmaritainmark henriemark twainmarriagemarriage debtmartin luther kingmartyrdommary eberstadtmaureen dowdmercymetaphysicsmid-life crisismildred jeffersonmodernitymodestymohammedmother teresamotivationmovie recommendationsnewmannewman's conversionnfpnietzschenon-violencenostalgiaobamaobjectification of womenobjectivity of truthopen discussionoppressionpassivitypaternalismpatrick o'brianpavperfectionpersonpersonal dignitypersonal well-beingpersonalismpersonspersons and powerpet peevephallic symbolsphenomenologypluralismplutopolandpopulation controlpornographypostmodernismpro-lifeprojectionprovidentialismprudishnesspurityrational animalreaganrecommendationsrecordingsrelativismreligionrepentanceretreat

Recent posts:

•  Frances Chesterton, kindred spirit 
•  Public morality and the common good 
•  Validating feelings 
•  Choice and borderline personality disorder (3)
•  A personalist approach to Natural Family Planning 
•  Fr. John Courtney Murray 
•  Christmas meditation 
•  Humbug 
•  A feast of beauty brought to you by mind-blowing technology 
•  Advent souls 
•  Should we say “no” to facebook? 
•  Persons and responsibility 
•  The vision at the center of it all 
•  Benedict on condoms (30)
•  Paternalism in the Hippocratic Oath (1)
•  Mildred Jefferson, heroine for life (1)
•  If the body is still there, so is the person 
•  Love and permanence 
•  Newman’s influence 
•  In Defense of Negativity (2)
•  The number 223 (1)
•  Fatiguing us into compliance 
•  Imagining communism 
•  Are we all equal, i.e. equally worthless? (3)
•  Cleansed but not saved (1)
•  119th birthday of Edith Stein (2)
•  121st birthday of Dietrich von Hildebrand, beautiful man 
•  RE: Truth? Who cares? 
•  Freedom 9: An overwhelming argument for free will from everyone`s experience 
•  Freedom 8: The Argument from the Self-contradiction of denying freedom (4)
•  Newman becomes Catholic (4)
•  Truth? Who cares? (1)
•  Personal bonds 
•  Sofia Tolstoy and feminism (3)
•  The modernity of Newman 
•  What’s wrong with this answer? 
•  Natural rights, witches and unicorns (17)
•  Benedict on Newman 
•  Personalism at our founding 
•  Is love not enough? (2)
•  Education in cyberspace? 
•  Newman Beatified today 
•  The personalist significance of involuntary emotions (2)
•  Deliberations 
•  It is not good for man to be alone (7)
•  Resisting the objectification women (3)
•  Von Hildebrand conference in Rome 
•  Karol Wojtyla, great gift to the world 
•  Von Hildebrand conference in Rome 
•  The enemy within 
•  “The emperor’s new clothes” put to music! (5)
•  Sheena Duncan, RIP 
•  Protecting children 
•  Legion of Christ taken to task (2)
•  Religion of Peace? (2)
•  Theological virtues don’t obviate the claims of natural justice 
•  Privacy for animals 
•  Megan McArdle on marriage 
•  Mark Twain on marriage 
•  Husbands, love your wives (3)
•  Splitting the moral atom 
•  Midlife care for the soul 
•  Poland 
•  Personal responsibility or paternalism? 
•  Child brides 
•  Hatred of the Church 
•  Personal encounter with God the center of true faith 
•  Power corrupts 
•  The Dreyfus affair and clerical sex abuse 
•  Recommended reading 
•  Scruton on giving 
•  Penitence 
•  The priority of the personal in human happiness 
•  The personification of evil (3)
•  John Allen on Benedict’s handling of the issue (14)
•  Weigel on the sex scandals in the Church (1)
•  What is criticism? (1)
•  What is conscience? (52)
•  The nanny becomes a bully 
•  Power vs. service 
•  the de-personalizing Legion of Christ (1)
•  Christians in public 
•  Satanism in the Vatican (3)
•  Freedom has to come from within (4)
•  Al Qaida calls for more murder 
•  Intimidation vs. freedom in religion 
•  Son of Hamas fingers Allah as the source of Islamic terror 
•  Josef Seifert calls on PAV President to step down (4)
•  Intimacy without love: an illustration 
•  Bill Buckley on the morality of the last days 
•  Intimacy without love damages the spirit (24)
•  Kleist’s take on modernity (5)
•  Lenten Reading 
•  Christian and Islamic visions of love 
•  Conflating toughness and bullying (1)
•  Ayn Rand’s false philosophy (2)
•  Gift and grateful striving: Personalist Insight of the Day (PID) (2)
•  The curse and the gift of being Irish (2)
•  Defeating corruption 
•  Equality of persons